The QNAP TS-251A versus QNAP TS-253B NAS – Which one deserves your money?
Rob Andrews
Comparing the home use TS-251A NAS and the SMB TS-253B NAS from QNAP
What can both NAS server’s do? Before I get down to which of these units is better at what task, I think it is important to know the things that BOTH of these NAS devices can do. So, whether you decide upon older but cheaper QNAP TS-251A or the higher priced but far more able QNAP TS-253B NAS, you will definitely be able to:
Host a Virtualisation or Container Platform – setup and run multiple VMs, supporting multiple Operating systems and enhanced by the Docker app, Container Station
Full access to your media from mobile devices, PC, Laptop and console devices
Have both network access from your LAN or over the internet, as well as DIRECT access via USB 3.0 to the contents of the NAS at all times
Have a remote control included that provides full media control from the comfort of your sofa and via your HDMI enabled TV. However the type of remote differs dependently on the unit.
The QNAP TS-453B NAS Remote control:The QNAP TS-451A NAS Remote control:
Serve as a cross platform service – bridging connections and transfers of files between Mac and Windows systems over the network
Heavily support background data checks and comprehensive snapshot technology meaning you will have an equal amount of backup options whichever you go for. As well as migration, connection and interaction with existing cloud services like dropbox, Google Drive ElephantDrive
Create a comprehensive Surveillance solutions, supporting multiple IP cameras and even arriving with some licences included
Access exactly the same NAS OS that is updated regularly and has a huge app store to really customise your setup to make it your own
What are the Pros and Cons of the TS-253B New NAS from QNAP?
VALUE
For the pure funtionality and ability, you will struggle to do better than this NAS. It is designed to be the answer to your NAS needs and delivers in almost everyway. It brings years of technical evolution and innovation to a climax and produces a fantastic little NAS solution in the TS-253B
FEATURES
easily one of the most fully featured NAS servers in this price range available to date! With many of the key hardware and software applications of the QNAP TVS-473, TS-451A, TS-453A and more – but all available in this single NAS. Dual HDMI, DUAL LAN, PCIe Slot, SD Card reader, Quick Connect DAS, one touch USB 3.0 Copy, Hot Swapping, new and improved remote control and more. This is fast becoming the home and SMB NAS to beat in 2017
PERFORMANCE
Supporting everything from Plex, Kodi over HDMI in Linux Station, VMs, standalone surveillance, all RAID levels, DLNA support, apple time machine, Mac and Windows full RTRRR, QVR Pro Beta and more – you will struggle to find something this NAS cannot do
DESIGN
Very unique chassis design from QNAP in the newly release TS-253B NAS for 2017. It is both compact and remarkably packed with features. The removable front panel acts as both protection for the HDD trays and a preventative measure for dust. Also the addition of an LCD panel, SD Card Reader, Direct Attached Connection and 1 Touch copy button mean this small little NAS has an incredible number of features
VALUE
Misses the mark just a little without arriving with TB3 connectivity and some users may be put off by the plastic chassis
FEATURES
Those looking for something for enterprise use will perhaps be better looking for something in the TVS-1282 Series in an i5 or i7. This NAS is about being able to do many, many things very well, rather than 1 or 2 things incredibly
PERFORMANCE
We just wish QNAP released the Thunderbolt 3 Card to buy seperately. A two Bay Thunderbolt 3 NAS would be incredible! Such a shame…but you never know
DESIGN
Shame it is almost 80% plastic externally. Yes that reduces noise and makes it quite, but some may be put off by this
What are the Pros and Cons of the older but well known TS-251A NAS released in 2016?
VALUE
Originally released at a rather high price tag of £240 ex.VAT, but since release the price has dipped down to a more comfortable £220+ without VAT, it is a more attractive NAS purchase
FEATURES
Excellent system performance, ideal for centralized management, file sharing and backup USB QuickAccess port for accessing files without needing a network connection – Easy accessible front USB3 to backup your external drive one way or another. Useful SD card slot eliminates necessity for a cable to connect photo camera. Bi directional micro USB connection let you connect this NAS directly to your PC to upload or download any files. Quick backup button on the front saves a lot of time to quickly backup your external hard drive. Supports 4K hardware decoding and transcodes 4K H.264 videos on-the-fly or offline Enjoy the best audio-visual experience with HDMI output, multi-channel surround sound and the free remote control
PERFORMANCE
The TS-251A is powered by an advanced 14nm Intel® Celeron® dual-core 1.6GHz processor that features low TDP (only 6 watts) and can automatically burst up to 2.48GHz. Coupled with dual-channel 2/4GB DDR3L-1600 dual-channel RAM (upgradable to 8GB), dual Gigabit LAN ports, and SATA 6Gb/s, the TS-451A can deliver up to 213.4 MB/s throughput for optimizing mission-critical tasks while still being energy efficient. The TS-251A also features Intel® AES-NI hardware-accelerated encryption to deliver up to 205.14 MB/s throughput with AES 256-bit throughput with AES-NI encryption for both full NAS volume and shared folders, boosting system performance & security while ensuring the safety of sensitive business data stored in the NAS
DESIGN
A very compact and versatile chassis, where sound is dampened by the less metallic chassis. Also the white and metallic blue colour scheme looks fantastic in an all Mac environment.
VALUE
Hardware specs are not as cheap as similar network drives available and you are paying extra for the USB DAS connection
FEATURES
Build a personal karaoke system with OceanKTV Linux Station supports Ubuntu® with direct output via HDMI A hybrid approach to virtualization: Virtualization Station & Container Station Supports Virtual JBOD (VJBOD) to maximize the storage utilization of multiple QNAP NAS units
PERFORMANCE
Transfer speeds are up to 100MB/s when connecting directly to a PC.
DESIGN
Using the chassis from the TS-231+, it is almost entirely plastic. Might put some off.