The Seagate Firecuda 540 vs MSI Spatium M570 Gen5 SSD – Which Should You Buy?
It’s been a gradual journey, but Gen 5 m.2 NVMe SSDs are now more accessible, witnessing price reductions, and being introduced by prominent SSD brands. The measured emergence of Gen 5 in the SSD realm can partly be linked to the disruptions caused by the 2020 pandemic affecting Gen 5 production. The assimilation into motherboards and the shift of SSDs from Gen 4 to Gen 5 has also been unhurried. Gen 5 boasts superior performance attributes, bolstered by advanced controllers from top manufacturers. However, its uptake at the motherboard and system stages has been somewhat delayed. While Gen 5 SSDs are currently available for purchase, how consistently you can tap into their optimal performance remains a topic of debate. Still, for those considering a drive for the next half-decade, looking ahead and ensuring future compatibility is prudent. With Gen 5 becoming both more economical and sophisticated, it’s set to overshadow and eventually supersede Gen 4. Therefore, for anyone contemplating a top-tier SSD for upcoming years, selecting a Gen 5 SSD is a forward-thinking move. Today, we’ll be contrasting two initial Gen 5 SSD offerings: the MSI Spatium M570 and Seagate Firecuda 540. At an initial look, these SSDs might appear comparable due to the early stage of Gen 5, but they each have distinct visions for what a Gen 5 SSD should offer. Let’s delve into their detailed comparison.
Seagate Firecuda 540 NVMe SSD | MSI Spatium M570 NVMe SSD |
Check Amazon |
Check Amazon |
Comparing MSI Spatium M570 and Seagate Firecuda 540 Hardware Specifications
The solid-state drive (SSD) market is continually evolving, and with the introduction of PCIe Gen 5 SSDs, consumers have more options than ever. Today, we’re focusing on two prominent contenders in the Gen5 arena: Seagate’s Firecuda 540 and MSI’s Spatium M570. Let’s dive deep into their specifications to understand how they fare against each other.. For regular consumers, Gen 5 has been accessible for nearly 2 years, though it’s more accurate to say about 18 months if we factor in the actual purchase timeframe online. On the other hand, in the data center and corporate spheres, Gen 5 has been operational for almost 3 years. This duration has paved the way for continuous research, refinement, and breakthroughs. As is typical in the SSD industry, Phison was among the pioneers to introduce a Gen 5 controller, showcasing their E26 controller. They subsequently released several other versions tailored for business needs and efficiency, such as the DRAMless E31. Soon after, entities like Integrate and Silicon Motion entered the competition. This evolution prompted many SSD manufacturers to finalize their strategies for Gen 5 SSDs early on (without even considering proprietary brands like Samsung and WD). At the same time, there were advances in storage capability and flash tech, which allowed for heightened layer counts and the prospect of more compact storage without compromising the superior Gen 5 performance benchmarks, as well as the anticipated resilience and longevity. Considering that these two Gen 5 SSDs represent some of the initial releases in the market, their performance attributes are closely matched. Still, minor variances in I/O values and longevity might render some contrasts more pronounced than others in a direct comparison. Let’s see how the MSI Spatium M570 and Seagate Firecuda 540 measure up technically:
Overall Specifications
Feature | Seagate Firecuda 540 | MSI Spatium M570 |
---|---|---|
Manufacturer | Seagate | MSI |
Name/Series | Firecuda 540 | Spatium M570 |
Capacities | 1-2-4TB | 1-2TB |
PCIe Gen | PCIe Gen 5×4 | PCIe Gen 5×4 |
Controller | Phison E26 | Phison E26 |
NVMe Rev. | NVMe 2.0 | NVMe 2.0 |
NAND Type | 3D TLC Micron B58R | 3D TLC Micron B58R |
NAND Layer | 232L | 232L |
Inclusive Heatsink? | No (inc Heatshield) | Yes (Vented) |
Price Per TB (2TB) | $148/TB | $177 |
DWPD | 0.55DWPD | 0.38DWPD |
MTBF | 2 Million Hours | 1.6 Million Hours |
Warranty | 5yrs + 3yrs Data Rec | 5yrs |
Detailed 1TB Model Specifications
Feature | Seagate Firecuda 540 | MSI Spatium M570 |
---|---|---|
1TB Model ID | ZP1000GM3A004 | TBC |
Price | $189 | $179 |
Seq Read Speed | 9.5GB/s | 9.5GB/s |
Seq Write Speed | 8.5GB/s | 8.5GB/s |
4K Random Read IOPS | 1.3 Million | 1.3 Million |
4K Random Write IOPS | 1.5 Million | 1.5 Million |
TBW | 1000TBW | 700TBW |
Detailed 2TB Model Specifications
Feature | Seagate Firecuda 540 | MSI Spatium M570 |
---|---|---|
2TB Model ID | ZP2000GM3A004 | S78-440Q560-P83 |
Price | $299 | $349.99 |
Seq Read Speed | 10GB/s | 10GB/s |
Seq Write Speed | 10GB/s | 10GB/s |
4K Random Read IOPS | 1.5 Million | 1.4 Million |
4K Random Write IOPS | 1.5 Million | 1.5 Million |
TBW | 2000TBW | 1400TBW |
On paper, both SSDs showcase impressive stats that are in line with what consumers would expect from a Gen5 SSD. The Seagate Firecuda 540 offers a slightly wider range of capacities, including a 4TB option, and boasts a more extensive warranty period when considering data recovery. However, the MSI Spatium M570 seems to offer better value in the 1TB category, coming in slightly cheaper. It also includes an integrated vented heatsink, which can be advantageous depending on the user’s setup. The real decision comes down to specific requirements, brand loyalty, and budget. Given the closely matched specs, potential buyers should also consider other factors like software support, customer reviews, and compatibility with their systems. Both drives represent the cutting edge of SSD technology and promise a significant performance boost over their Gen4 predecessors. If you’re not well-versed in SSD terminology, such as DWPD, IOPS, and TBW, the video below is a useful resource. It provides a detailed breakdown of common solid-state drive terminologies, helping you discern the subtle contrasts between these two models.
In the fast-paced arena of solid-state drives, the battle between the Seagate Firecuda 540 and the MSI Spatium M570 represents a compelling matchup for any tech enthusiast. Both drives, being of the Gen5 pedigree, promise blistering speeds and improved overall performance compared to their Gen4 counterparts.
The Seagate Firecuda 540, with its broader capacity range, provides potential buyers the flexibility to choose based on their storage needs, even catering to those seeking a massive 4TB option. This flexibility is further accentuated by its extensive warranty, especially with the added bonus of data recovery – a feature often overlooked but immensely valuable in safeguarding one’s data. On the other side, the MSI Spatium M570 appears to lean towards offering greater value, particularly in the 1TB model where its price undercuts the Firecuda slightly. Beyond just the numbers, the Spatium M570 showcases a thoughtful design by integrating a vented heatsink. This inclusion could be crucial for potential buyers who prioritize thermal management, especially given the performance levels these drives operate at. Yet, as with all technological purchases, the decision isn’t purely black and white. While specifications provide a solid foundation for comparison, real-world performance, software support, and user experiences play a significant role. It’s essential to consider compatibility with specific system setups, ease of installation, and the longevity of performance. Moreover, brand loyalty, arising from past experiences with customer service and product reliability, might tip the scales for some.
In the grand scheme, it’s exhilarating to see how far SSD technology has come. Both the Firecuda 540 and Spatium M570 stand as testaments to the leaps and bounds the industry has made, and their offerings bode well for the future. As Gen5 SSDs continue to become more mainstream and further innovations arise, consumers stand to benefit the most. Whether you’re a hardcore gamer seeking reduced load times, a content creator desiring faster render speeds, or just someone who craves a zippy computing experience, both these SSDs present a promising step forward. Making an informed choice now will not only cater to present needs but also ensure that your tech setup is future-proofed for the innovations around the corner.
Seagate Firecuda 540 NVMe SSD | MSI Spatium M570 NVMe SSD |
Check Amazon |
Check Amazon |
🔒 Join Inner Circle
Get an alert every time something gets added to this specific article!
This description contains links to Amazon. These links will take you to some of the products mentioned in today's content. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Visit the NASCompares Deal Finder to find the best place to buy this device in your region, based on Service, Support and Reputation - Just Search for your NAS Drive in the Box Below
Need Advice on Data Storage from an Expert?
Finally, for free advice about your setup, just leave a message in the comments below here at NASCompares.com and we will get back to you. Need Help? Where possible (and where appropriate) please provide as much information about your requirements, as then I can arrange the best answer and solution to your needs. Do not worry about your e-mail address being required, it will NOT be used in a mailing list and will NOT be used in any way other than to respond to your enquiry.(Early Access) COOL NAS UPGRADES (You might Not Know About)
(Early Access) UGREEN NAS SERIES - SHOULD YOU BUY?
(Early Access) DIY NAS - The Cost of Building a Synology NAS?
(Early Access) The Best DIY NAS Builds for Under $500
(Early Access) DIY NAS vs Lockerstor Gen 3 - IS IT WORTH $1299 ???
(Early Access) Lockerstor Gen 3 Series - SHOULD YOU BUY ONE?
(Early Access) Asustor ADM 5 Software Review - Should Synology Be Worried?
(Early Access) Best 8-Bay NAS of 2024
(Early Access) Best 4-Bay NAS of 2024
(Early Access) Best 2-Bay NAS of 2024
(Early Access) Best Value NAS of 2024 - SAVE SOME MONEY!
(Early Access) Lockerstor 4 Gen3 Review - GO HOME EVERYONE
Access content via Patreon or KO-FI
I can sympathize about the seagulls. In any big city, you’ve got to deal with pigeons, unless you’re near water, in which case seagulls are bigger, a lot noisier, and produce a lot more poop. We have a ton of them in Chicago and the surrounding suburbs.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
14:52
Crucial T700 right now is running for $269 as of 05-07-2024 10:00am, prices are coming down, though slowly. And pretty soon Gen5 is going to be the norm.
Come Black Friday 2024, these are going to drop to around $160 to $180 for 2TB.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
forget the shotgun mate get some Alka-Seltzer tabs stops pesky seagulls in their tracks 😉
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Here, I’ll save everyone some time….no. Until ALL motherboards can run a full speed GPU at Gen 5 AND a Gen 5 NVME SSD, no. Buy two Gen 4’s and raid 0 them, it will be just as fast, if not faster. Not to mention you’ll save money on your motherboard and drives.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
That’d be interesting to touch GPU NVMe direct , aka gpus w/NVMe drives, in context of Gen4 vs Gen5 NVMe drives
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
wow just keep on talking while birds are squealing away, huh?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
For gamers like me, i didn’t see any differences between Gen 5, Gen 4, even Gen 3 Nvme SSD, jumping from Gen 3 to Gen 5 SSD only makes game loading screen 1-2 seconds faster.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Idk why but when I hear them seagulls and he says “I really hate seagulls” I end up laughing
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Is that costs cup part of the decor ????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Given that many “refresh” Motherboards are providing Thunderbolt 4 .. is it safe to say that ‘midi latency’ with Intel CPU’s can be as readily minimized as with the Apple Mac Studio or Mac Mini ? ~ I have heard that Intel CPu’s have an intrinsic latency issue that increases midi latency that does not exist in the Mac Silicon integrated processors. Can you shed some light on that issue. ~There are some decent Intel Z790 motherboards out now that have TB4 and PCIe / M.2. gen 5. Is it safe to assume that with the new MOBOs my latency issue ( I’ve been running an older Del quad core up till now) will be resolved. ~My intended build (for Audio production only hence no graphics card) setup is; i7-14700K, Possibly with the ASUS Z790 Maximums Dark Hero. ~As with all new Z790 MOBOs it seem there is going to be ‘some’ wasted lane action due to bifurcation. The Dark Hero, as I understand it, has 1 Gen 5 M.2 and 1 Gen 4 M.2 going directly through the Processor and additional Gen 4 M.2 through chipset. This seems as close to the integrated Mac setup as one might expect with a Z790 board ,,,and still is slightly less expensive than the Mac Studio with sufficient storage and Ram. BUT will it(with a TB interface) resolve my long term MIDI latency issue? Please advise!? Thanks! Great videos!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
If you want to remove the seagalls, rather than using a shootgun (Why not?) use Davinci resolve Studio : your problem will be solved in 5 minutes
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I like to try the Samsung MZ1L23T8HBLA-00A07 PM9A3 3.8TB NVMe PCIe Gen4, does anybody know about this drive ?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thank goodness you are about the only one I’ve come across who knows how to pronounce Asus (Ace-Us). So many others annoyingly call it A-Sooos. They obviously haven’t looked up the origin of the company name.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I want to see you put one in a ps5
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Robbie, the seagulls heard what you said. Every word.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Off topic, is it possible to use Samsung 980 pro 2tb with heatsink on a laptop? or I have to remove that builtin heatsink?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
What’s the BEST SSD for PS5?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Flying rats make their appearance
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
The seagulls bring a smile to my face as does your reaction. What do you think about replacing your B-roll motorway background with some metaphorical seagull footage? Landing, gliding, fighting, picking through garbage, saving small children who have drifted out to sea. (not sure, that last one might be dolphins) In any case, what you and the team do and how you do it is greatly appreciated.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I’m blown away by the fact how overheating is a normal and expected behaviour of Gen5 NVMe drives. Necessity for large heatsinks and even active cooling solutions totally eliminates the whole point of having a tiny embedded storage attached directly to motherboard. What gives..?!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
From the looks of it, none of those Motherboards support PCIe 5.0 on the M.2 slots.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I’ll buy one once SK Hynix release theirs
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
The only reason why I got a Gen 5 motherboard is I’ll be upgrading in a couple of years gen-5 is way too early to adopt anything from it
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I don’t mind the seagulls. Ever seen Jonathan Seagull (the movie)? Advise watching stoned. It’s an old hippie movie. LOL
Yeah I’ll wait a bit for equipping my ASRock Live mixer B650 with a Gen 5. Black Friday perhaps.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Watching with an open window behind me, thought they were here!????????????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
This is easy.
pcie gen 3 is the way to go, espcecially due to thermals.
gen4 and gen5 get needlessly hot for “performance” most people won’t even need
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Robbie will never be able to change locations to one without seagulls without losing an iconic part of his channel’s aesthetic.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Love the Seagulls ????????????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
lol this is easy it isn’t worth it, many folks don’t even need gen4 unless they want drive for playstation 5
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Is it worth buying some nvme gen 5 to put them in a ds1621+ for example? And for example in a tvs-862x?I think the connections of these NAS are gen 3, right?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I picked up two 2 TB Samsung 990 Pro PCIe 4 SSDs for $129 each during Prime Day. That will tide me over until my next platform upgrade probably.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
????????????????????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
????????????????????????????????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Hello
REPLY ON YOUTUBE