A Guide to the Best 10GbE NAS Drives
Data continues to grow exponentially, with everyday devices generating substantial amounts of data. High-resolution photos, 4K Ultra HD HDR movies, and internet connections surpassing gigabit speeds have become the norm. This surge in data creation and transfer has highlighted the limitations of the traditional 1GbE (RJ45) LAN/WAN ports, often causing network bottlenecks. In the past year, client hardware like phones, laptops, TVs, and tablets have adapted to this challenge, increasingly incorporating advanced WiFi protocols such as WiFi 6 (802.11ax). Similarly, in the realm of Network Attached Storage (NAS), addressing bandwidth limitations has been a focus for several years, with one of the key solutions being the adoption of 10GbE technology. 10GbE, offering ten times the bandwidth of the conventional 1GbE, enables network transmissions to exceed 1,000MB/s. Although 10G technology has been around for a while, it’s only in the last few years, particularly in 2023 and 2024, that it has become significantly more affordable. This price reduction has made it feasible for both home and business users to upgrade. The cost of 10G adapter cards has dropped to under £100, and network switches are now priced only slightly higher than their 1G counterparts. Furthermore, in some instances, the physical compatibility of 1G and 10G is identical (Copper RJ45), simplifying upgrades and allowing for considerable hardware reuse.
10GbE has become much more accessible than previously anticipated. To assist in your decision-making process, below is a video detailing numerous reasons to upgrade to or opt out of 10GbE, which could be helpful in your search for the best 10GbE NAS to buy in 2024.
Best NAS of the Year
|
Key Features of Top 10GbE NAS Drives in 2024
When exploring the various 10GbE NAS drives available, it’s crucial to recognize that they are not all created equal. Despite the temptation of lower-priced models from emerging brands, these often lack durability and comprehensive features. Here are the essential features that the best 10GbE NAS drives, regardless of brand, should include:
1. **Integrated Hardware and Software**: Includes a web browser interface, mobile and desktop apps for backup, media streaming, surveillance, and file management.
2. **Multi-OS Compatibility**: Accessible via Windows, Mac, Android, and Linux.
3. **Warranty**: Typically 2-3 years, extendable to 5 years.
4. **Network and Remote Access**: Local network access and secure remote access with brand-supported services at no extra cost.
5. **Support for Latest Hard Drives**: Compatibility with the latest 20TB NAS hard drives.
6. **RAID Support**: Multiple drive configurations for data protection and performance.
7. **Regular Updates**: Frequent updates for security, features, and services.
8. **Cloud and Enterprise Service Integration**: Syncing capabilities with cloud services like Google Drive, Dropbox, and OneDrive, and enterprise services such as AWS and Azure.
9. **Shared Drive Hosting**: Ability to host a synchronized drive on your device, visible in the native file manager.
10. **Direct Network Connectivity**: Access via ethernet for 100MB/s or higher connectivity.
11. **Backup and Sync Tools**: Client-side tools for regular backups of files and system data.
Ensure any 10GbE NAS you consider, beyond the top recommendations, includes these features. These aspects are often compromised in cheaper models, resulting in less proficient NAS servers. Let’s now look at the best 10GbE NAS drives to buy right now.
Honourable Mention, Good Value 10GbE – Terramaster T9-450 NAS
0-198TB, 9-Bays, 2x PCIe Gen 3 M.2 NVMe 2280, Intel C3558R Atom Quad Core CPU, 8-32GB Memory, 2x 10GbE SFP, 1x 2.5GbE Port, PCIe Slot (TBC), 2yr Warranty
Current Price/Availability on Amazon – $999-1099
Hardware Review – LINK
YouTube Video Review – Watch
What I said in my review May ’23:
Terramaster has really changed the playing field with the T9-450 NAS. I was already a big fan of their latest generation of 6-Bay, 9-Bay and 12-Bay desktop chassis – providing a pretty substantial amount of storage in a tower design that borrows ventilation methodology traditionally found in rackmounts, but the T9-450 takes this logic and doubles down on it hard. The dual 10GbE on the system means that, despite it’s comparatively modest price point (when comparing against similar scale solutions from Synology and QNAP) you genuinely have a solution with the potential to allow you to enjoy every single MB/s or GB/s of your RAID externally. This is further bolstered with additional 2.5GbE ports, m.2 NVMe bays, uncomplicated support of HDDs/SSDs and just generally a very sensible system that shows how much Terramaster has matured as a brand. The TOS software is still not quite up there with Synology’s DSM or QNAP’s QTS in terms of ease of use and AAA+ features, but it is definitely a great entry point OS that has tighted it’s security since the brand was targetted by a ransomware group (along with other brands, they were affected by Deadbolt attacks) – it certainly lacks some of the background optimization of it’s competitors, but then this is reflected in the budget of the system too.
The internal PCIe slot that has been largely ignored is a bit of a missed opportunity and I am not a big fan of how they have addressed memory compatibility, but overall it is very, very tough to criticise the T9-450 NAS when you factor in the value of the package here. Factor in that you can very easily swap out the OS for many others, and it largely silences alot of the negatives here too. Overall, the T9-450 could potentially be the best NAS that Terramster has ever released and if they continue to address later releases with the same level of hardware value, this could definitely give the bigger names in the industry something of a headache down the road. I highly recommend this system for its value and performance potential!
 DEAL WATCH – Is It On Offer Right Now?These Offers are Checked Daily
|
Best All Round 10GbE NAS for HW and SW – Synology DS1823xs+ NAS
0-176TB, 8-Bays, 2x NVMe Cache Bays, Quad-Core Ryzen V1780B 3.4Ghz CPU, 8-32GB DDR4 ECC Memory, 1x 10GbE, 2x 1Gbe Port, 1x PCIe 3×8 Upgrade Slot, 5yr Warranty
Current Price/Availability on Amazon – $1799
Hardware Review – LINK
YouTube Video Review – Watch Long Review – Watch Short Review
What I said in my review March ’23:
If you are looking for a solid and confident move away from expensive long-term cloud subscription services, away from your defunct Drobo system or simply looking for a Synology NAS that has good hardware inside, outside and with DSM all over it – the DS1823xs+ NAS is a very solid choice indeed! With a huge degree of expandability and upgradability open to the end user to scale with later in the system’s life, extensive long-term committed software support and that 5yrs hardware warranty out the box – this is a system that is clearly designed for the long-haul and as soon as you factor in the complete hardware+software nature of this purchase with DSM included, it’s a very tasty box! There are a few odd choices here or there (e.g M.2 NVMe Pools not presented in the way some might like and HDD/SSD compatibility that clearly favours the enterprise tier), this is still easily the most powerful and capable 8-Bay system that Synology has ever produced. Whether you are a small, medium or large business user, this system has a large amount of potential for your data and has the horsepower for multiple VMs, large-scale surveillance, widespread backups, broad multi-user access and all of these running at the same time in a remarkably compact package.
That said, the DS1823xs+ NAS has a little bit of an identity crisis when you scale it up with the rest of the larger tiers of the Synology portfolio and, although I genuinely like it, seems to be a system that exists BETWEEN the Synology PLUS and XS series (see my points about the RS2423+) and when you look at it in that context, it sees the tiniest bit more expensive than it should be. If you are looking at the DS1823xs+ NAS and fully intend to scale up the storage, external bandwidth or memory in the next two years, I would recommend skipping this and opting for the DS3622xs+ instead. However, the base model of the DS1823xs+ has alot of ‘umpf’ under the bonnet and short of those hurdles for some on compatibility, the DS1823xs+ seemingly lives up to alot of it’s expectations!
|
DEAL WATCH – Is It On Offer Right Now? Synology DS1823xs+ 8 Bay NAS Desktop: High-Performance Storage Solution Amazon  UK 23.1 OFF (WAS 1819) [LINK] These Offers are Checked Daily
|
Best Storage 10GbE NAS – QNAP Triple Tier TS-855X Server
0-130TB SATA HDDs, 0-16TB SATA SSDs, 0-16TB 3×4 M.2 NVMes, 6+2+2-Bays, C5125 8-Core Atom CPU, 8-128GB Memory, 1x 10GbE and 2x 2.5GbE Ports, 2x PCIe 3×8 Slots, 3yr Warranty
Current Price/Availability on Amazon – $1300-1500
Hardware Review – LINK
YouTube Video Review – Watch
What I said in my review June ’23:
I have to say, I am INSANELY impressed by how much bang for buck is being included in the TS-855X and although it is not the most powerful device in the market (arguably intentionally, as it favours the more affordable Atom over a xeon), it is a sensible workhorse of a NAS. On the positive side, the QNAP TS-855X NAS comes with numerous strong selling points. The device offers large storage potential, especially with the ZFS file system, making it a powerhouse for data management. The choice of CPU is also sensible, providing a balance between performance and cost-effectiveness. The inclusion of the QTier tool is particularly appealing, adding a layer of efficiency to the storage management. Another big plus is the user-friendly GUI for ZFS in QuTS, making it accessible for users with varying levels of technical expertise. The three-tier storage options and support of ECC memory with a maximum of 128GB further enhance the device’s versatility and potential. Moreover, the TS-855X provides a wealth of expansion options and comes with 8 camera licenses with QVR Pro/QTS. The well-ventilated design contributes to thermal efficiency, ensuring optimal performance, while its support for the latest 22TB and soon-to-be-released 24TB drives future-proofs your investment.
However, the TS-855X is not without its drawbacks. While the two SATA SSD bays provide extra storage options, they would have been better if they were U.2 slots, which offer faster speeds. Although the device supports ECC memory, the initial 8GB memory in the base model is non-ECC, which might not be optimal for all ZFS services. The memory capacity might also be somewhat low for users with intensive data needs. Furthermore, the software can sometimes be inconsistent under heavy use, and it has a steeper learning curve compared to competitors like Synology. Finally, the pricing structure for the TS-855X is a mixed bag. While some users may find the cost reasonable given its features, others might feel it’s a bit steep for what it offers. Therefore, while the QNAP TS-855X NAS offers a plethora of attractive features and strong performance, it’s worth keeping in mind that a spend of a few hundred more dollars opens the door to Intel Core-powered NAS in the TVS-hx74 series or more powerful Xeon triple-tiered systems such as the TVS-h1288X. If you want power, but on a budget, it’s a great choice!
|
DEAL WATCH – Is It On Offer Right Now? QNAP TS-855X-8G 8 Bay Desktop NAS Amazon UK 33.81 OFF (WAS 1669) [LINK] These Offers are Checked Daily
|
Best Value 10GbE NVMe NAS – The Asustor Flashstor 12 Pro NVMe Flash Server
0-96TB, 12x M.2 NVMe 3×1 Bays, Supports 2x USB Expansions, N5105/N5095 4-Core CPU, 4-16GB DDR4 (non-ECC) Memory, 1x 10Gbe Port, 3yr Warranty
Current Price/Availability on Amazon – $799
Hardware Review – LINK
YouTube Video Review HERE)
What I said in my review June ’23:
I cannot stress enough how impressed I am that the Flashstor 6 and Flashstor 12 Pro are priced at $499 and $860, respectively, given the level of hardware on offer here. These are by no means enterprise-grade NAS server solutions, nor should they be thought of as such. However, given the cost of typical fully featured 4x HDD solutions from their competitors and the brand themselves, which often start at $550 and above, it is quite remarkable that the six M.2 SSD system with comparable internal hardware comes in at $499. As long as a user keeps their expectations in line with what this cost versus its capabilities, it’s really tough to argue with the price point that these two devices have arrived at on the market. The Asustor FS6712X Flashstor 12 Pro NAS presents a unique offering in the NAS market, leveraging NVMe technology to provide high-capacity, ultra-high-performance storage. The device’s design, with its rhombus-shaped enclosure and twelve M.2 NVMe slots, sets it apart from traditional NAS devices and offers a sleek and modern aesthetic.
The tool-less drive installation mechanism makes it easy to set up and expand the storage capacity. However, there are some considerations to keep in mind. The limited number of PCIe lanes provided by the Intel Celeron N5105 processor may restrict the performance of high-speed NVMe drives. The single 10GbE LAN port also presents a potential network bottleneck, limiting the device’s overall network performance. Users seeking maximum performance and network throughput may find alternative solutions better suited to their needs. Despite these limitations, the FS6712X shines as a storage solution for users who prioritize high-capacity storage, quiet operation, and low power consumption. The device’s ability to directly output 4K video, along with its range of Asustor-approved apps, makes it an excellent choice for media distribution and presentation. In terms of pricing, the FS6712X comes with a price tag of $850+. While this may appear high at first glance, it is comparable to 8 bay drive NAS SATA devices and many of those do not even include NVMe slots or 10GbE. Users looking for a more cost-effective option can consider the Flashstor 6, which offers half the number of slots and 2x 2.5GbE enabled ports for $499.
As the cost of flash modules continues to drop, and larger capacity drives become available all the way up to 8TB (even without QLC), the FS6712X provides an attractive solution for those seeking high-capacity and high-performance NAS storage. While some underlying performance relativity by the end user needs to be factored in and hardware limitations exist thanks to the use of that Celeron to remain budget-friendly, the FS6712X is a tremendously smart move by Asustor. A well-designed NAS that presents a much more confident solution demonstrating the benefits of NVMe-focused NAS devices to an audience that would have assumed such things are way, WAY outside the realms of affordability!
|
DEAL WATCH – Is It On Offer Right Now? Asustor FS6706T Flashstor 6 $419 AAAwave  USA $419 ($30 OFF with code) [LINK] Asustor Flashstor 12 Pro FS6712X - 12 Bay All-SSD NAS, Quad-Core 2.0GHz, 12 M.2 Amazon UK 50 OFF (WAS 789) [LINK] These Offers are Checked Daily
|
Need More Help Choosing the right NAS?
Choosing the right data storage solution for your needs can be very intimidating and it’s never too late to ask for help. With options ranging from NAS to DAS, Thunderbolt to SAS and connecting everything up so you can access all your lovely data at the touch of a button can be a lot simpler than you think. If you want some tips, guidance or help with everything from compatibility to suitability of a solution for you, why not drop me a message below and I will get back to you as soon as possible with what you should go for, its suitability and the best place to get it. This service is designed without profit in mind and in order to help you with your data storage needs, so I will try to answer your questions as soon as possible. Just enter in a few details of your setup, storage requirements and (in the case of buying a new solution) your budget – then me and Eddie the Web guy can help you with your question. This is a completely free service, is NOT provided with profit in mind and is manned by two humans (no bots, no automated replies, etc). Assistance might take an extra day or two (the service gets a lot of visitors) but we do try to answer every message. If you want to support this service, you can find out how to donate HERE. Otherwise, you can still just message us for free advice anyway!
📧 SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER 🔔
🔒 Join Inner Circle
Get an alert every time something gets added to this specific article!
This description contains links to Amazon. These links will take you to some of the products mentioned in today's content. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Visit the NASCompares Deal Finder to find the best place to buy this device in your region, based on Service, Support and Reputation - Just Search for your NAS Drive in the Box Below
Need Advice on Data Storage from an Expert?
Finally, for free advice about your setup, just leave a message in the comments below here at NASCompares.com and we will get back to you.
Need Help?
Where possible (and where appropriate) please provide as much information about your requirements, as then I can arrange the best answer and solution to your needs. Do not worry about your e-mail address being required, it will NOT be used in a mailing list and will NOT be used in any way other than to respond to your enquiry.
TRY CHAT
Terms and Conditions
|
 |
(Early Access) COOL NAS UPGRADES (You might Not Know About)
(Early Access) UGREEN NAS SERIES - SHOULD YOU BUY?
(Early Access) DIY NAS - The Cost of Building a Synology NAS?
(Early Access) The Best DIY NAS Builds for Under $500
(Early Access) DIY NAS vs Lockerstor Gen 3 - IS IT WORTH $1299 ???
(Early Access) Lockerstor Gen 3 Series - SHOULD YOU BUY ONE?
(Early Access) Asustor ADM 5 Software Review - Should Synology Be Worried?
(Early Access) Best 8-Bay NAS of 2024
(Early Access) Best 4-Bay NAS of 2024
(Early Access) Best 2-Bay NAS of 2024
(Early Access) Best Value NAS of 2024 - SAVE SOME MONEY!
(Early Access) Lockerstor 4 Gen3 Review - GO HOME EVERYONE
Access content via Patreon or KO-FI
50:11. There are reports that the heatsink doesn’t touch the CPU area 100%…. So temperature could be lowered I guess
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
The only cool thing I like about synology is SHR, without that, you have tons of good alternatives, with that you don’t.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Why are you talking about £400 for SFP to RJ45 convertors? They’re like £45 each for Unifi branded ones, slightly less for the 10GTEK ones.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Will you be reviewing the T9-500 Pro or T12-500 Pro??
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Like drinking from a Freakin’ Fire Hose!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Synology made a bad mistake. Hard drive vendor lock and Synology hard drive rip off price. I thought about buying a Synology NAS, but now I won’t. It is not up to Synology to decide which hard drive brand can and cannot be used.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
There are *no* non-Synology drives on the compatibility list (September 2024). Hard drives are the bulk of a NAS price tag.
Synology 18TB drive – £940
Seagate Ironwolf Pro 18TB drive – £308
If I can’t use reasonably priced drives in this box then I will look elsewhere.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks,
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
A review without turning it on for us to see and more importantly: hear? I mean you are explaining a lot of good stuff and background information is really interesting. I do feel at some points you talk a lot, but you’re not really giving relevant for us information, like on performance. In my opinion you are really missing some critical points for this to be a good review.
What are the real life read/write/network transfer speeds?
You say you will test software run benchmarks, but I don’t see any links and when searching your channel for this model, this is only thing popping up. So did you never get around to it?
You say it’s meant to be a work horse. My experience is that Arom CPU’s tend to falter quite quickly when you try to run VM’s. Did you test if this “workhorse” can manage a couple of VM’s?
Did you test the tiered pool (hot, warm, cold)? Did you notice (meassure) a noticeable difference in real life with this?
I was really excited when I started watching the review but at the end felt disappointed. You did not even turn it on for us to hear and see. You did not put any real life performance information in it. If you do a follow up, feel free to let me know as there is not much out there on this particular model (which may have added to my disappointment in this review).
I hope you don’t take this badly, I’m trying to give constructive feedback/crticism, not trying to put you down. If I didn’t care about your quality, I would have just clicked on to the next one 🙂
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
You really really must understand the difference between “thousand gigs”, if it is Gbps or GBps. So, your “gigs”, are they 10 gigabits/s, or 10 gigabytes/s. You mix those numbers all the time, even within the same sentence, so really, just use Gbit/s in transmission, as adults do.
And promoting “RAID0” for anythig, is really sad, and really bad idea. Me, I only use RAID6, with already 1-2 extra spare cold HDDs available waiting for a single HDD crash. RMAs can then be done without any hurry, or worrying about data loss.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Excellent video, made my decision a lot easier. i for one need SHR.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I love the overall design, I hope some day they’ll make a 12 bay version in a rackmount form factor
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I rip my blu ray and 4k disks on my home pc and play them with my zidoo .I dont need the intel one with grafics for storing iso’s and playing them with my zidoo right and the DS1821 will do its work with 8 x 16 tb right?Thanks for the reply @NAScompares
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
And you for being the first and only one I have found that answered my question. “Can you populate this nas as you go? Thank you!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I wanted a native 10g network port. I bought the DS1823xs+ open box for $1200, have 32GB ram in it and dual 800GB Synology NVME’s in it for cache. I still haven’t reflashed it yet to be able to use any brand HDD’s. Next is I need to make a filtered air silence box so I’m not hearing the harddrive sounding like popcorn going all day, and hide it in my basement somewhere.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
“It is pretty important I hate Seagulls” – Aha, but I hope you do like NAS’?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Nicker can be CHFs? 🙂
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
do you speak english?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
why do you pay for things in knickers?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Really truly considering the ts 855x for my next NAS this year and you’re right there’s not a lot out there about this beauty yet. I would love to see it fitted with a GPU in one of the
PCIe slots for video transcoding running Plex Media server. Tune-up website says it’s compatible with various 3rd party cards. I may have to do the experiment myself.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
A few 8TB Sabrents in this bad boy would be amazing
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
this DS1821+ is 3 years old? is there an update to this? looking for an 8 bay, but something around $1,000, the DS1823+ is $1800
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Hi … i would like to ask you one thing
Am in a confusion. Should i go for synology 422+ or 822+ or asustor fashter 12 drive bcz my main usage is plex media server or just storage and access files from internet when i am outside and save pics while am outside .. .. wht you say … which could be a better option AND ONE MORE OPTION IS QNAP 435 XEU ,,, I LIKE RACK MOUNT SYSTEM BCZ MY ALL MEDIA THINGS ARE INSTALLED IN RACK ? Please tell me which could be a better option
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I rarely react, but I have to say I love your Channel. Always check u before I buy Anything
I hate seagulls too
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Not too familiar with this set up. What is the raw storage capacity for this device? Looks slick!
Depends on media inside.
It’s been 14 months since the DS1823xs+ was “unveiled,” half a year since this video was made. The DS1821+ is still selling for 1,000 USD. Has anyone else been waiting for the price to drop?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Is it worth buying DS1821+ in 2024?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Watching this video when my 1821 gets delivered tomorrow and I feel better
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I would love to see someone run a test on the TS 855x with a 3rd party GPU someday.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
In the US we get nest business day replacement on xs. Makes sense for business… but lack of shr is a bummer for sure.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks for sharing this comparison. Your delivery is hilarious… #NewSubscriber
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
THX !
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
would this NAS be capable of 2 editor users simultaneously ?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
The issue that concerns me with the SD1821+ is that you can not go above 108TB in the same volume, which means if I use a high-capacity HDD, I need to break it down into multiple volumes. This is the question that I do not have an answer for… Will I lose throughput speed since each volume will have fewer drives???
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks, great detail in the video, especially around capabilities to mix’n’match storage into separate RAID groups. Any chance you’ve done performance benchmarks using RAID10? I’m a fan of RAID10 despite the storage capacity hit, due to the low impact on CPU and typically higher throughputs.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks for your video. Do you know when the 1824+ will come onto the market? I’ve been waiting for it for a year now.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks, your benchmark result of <800 MB/s sequential write (Overall) is not far from what I am getting. This is a real world performance. Too bad it cannot hit 1GB/s constant write speed. For others who are interested, initial sequential write speed is close to 1GB/s for first 5sec, after that 850MB/s until 30sec, then dropped to ~600MB/s until the end. Testing using 100GB file. One more unofficial fact is this N5105 works with 32GB Ram although intel specify 16GB as max, and Asustor also put 16 max. I do not have 64GB ram to test. The 32GB Ram i have is stripped from my old laptop, ECC 3200 Mhz Ram (also works as non ECC). Adding ram from 16 to 32 does not help in write speed.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thank you, Rob! I am putting in an order for the 1821+ on your recommendation. Do you have any specific recommendation on which RAM sticks to pick up for this thing and how much will be enough. Do you recommend sticking with the analogy brand which I’ve heard is much more expensive? Is more automatically better.
I definitely am interested in have you help me with installation and configuring.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Way too wordy really needs to be re-edited
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I am searching for a replacement of my years-old ReadyNAS. Thanks for this video and your clear words. It saves me for spending much money on the wrong product. Still, in Jan 2024 there are just Synology-HDDs on the compatibility list. A 18TB-Synology-HD will cost 700EUR, a WD 18TB will cost around 310EUR.???? There is no way for me to spend my money on Synology, regardless how good the other features are. ????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I bought a DS1823xs+ because my DS1815+ no longer works so that I can continue to use their disks directly. Now it turned out that the NAS disks (WD 6TB RED) are apparently no longer compatible with the new DS1823xs+ !!!????
This is important because I would not have bought a Synology if I had known that they are only compatible with their own disks!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks for the review. This seemed very promising for what I wanted but the drive issue is a jaw dropping show stopper. Most of my drives are (and will likely continue to be) exos drives. Zero chance I am paying for hardware that requires me to buy only their branded (they don’t make them), overpriced drives.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Good video, I’m thinking about getting the 6 slot version for my storage needs at the lab!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
It’s pronounced ‘Rie-Zin’…Not Rie-ZON’ 🙂 (Almost as bad as your previous “Sa-LAIR-on’ debacle! 🙂
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I mean, who wouldn’t want to spend an extra ~$270 each (at just $600 each on Amazon!)on Synology branded 16 TB drives (x8, totaling just an extra $2160 more if stuffing it full of Synology drives instead of primitive WD Golds, etc… This policy should massively affect sales for home/pro-sumer use. (O(r pro-schumer as Brits and Aussies sometimes pronounce it!)
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I probably wrote this before on some other video you made, but it’s worth repeating: Great content!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Gave it a thumb’s up solely for the TL;DR at the beginning. Thought these were 2.5″ers, so not watching… but I loved that time saver.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Now if I only had $12,000 more to stuff it full of 12 ea 8 TB NVME drives! 🙂
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
We use Synology for ABB mainly. And design is pretty compact and well designed with small footprint.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I can’t really even put into words how EXCELLENT this video comparison is !!! No stupid long musical graphical into, he comes right to point and states the best one to buy right away in case you don’t want to watch the rest (I highly suggest watching the rest as Robbie explains his reasoning perfectly!) He knows his stuff, no wasted words, right to the point, and I had to laugh when he talks about all the specs with funny music and fast scrolling on the screen. Haha. I have over 15TB of family videos/pics, and loads of valuable documents. (House is surrounded by security cameras also and I’d to keep them on 24/7.) I have an assortment of storage solutions including google docs, eDrive, Carbonite, and external hard drives. Would be nice to have everything in one place and accessible anywhere, anytime by anyone I choose. Recently I discovered the world of NAS and it’s like “where have you been all my life?” Lol. After studying YouTube vids, I considered a 2 bay. Then I considered the DS923+, then watched a few more YouTube vids, and considered the DS1821+, then a few more vids and considered the DS1823xs+. This video is perfect timing for me !! Definitely going with the DS1821+ for all the reasons delineated by Robbie! My only question, as mentioned in previous comments, SHOULD I WAIT FOR THE DS1824+ ?????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Super Hero. Well said, well done. Thank you.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
This is the third time I see you on YouTube, I just subscribed. This review convinced me to keep watching your Chanel and follow your next reviews. Really good video and great review. Thank you so much.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Great video. Would you recommend this over the TS-H973AX-32G as a NAS to be used on a 10Gbe network for video editing storage?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Look, i love your videos… but please stop using “knicker” as a word for money ????????????
It sounds so wrong and sounds like a different word ????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
One interesting thing. Can we install 64 GB? Some old videos showed that could be done accepting the upgrade bang at any moment. Some of these could use ECC or no-ECC memory to 64 GB?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I’m interested in seeing your watch collection, man.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Given Synology seem to be stopping support for older devices at around the 8 year mark, and we’re almost in 2024, does this mean that the 1821+ has already kissed goodbye to 3/8ths of it’s support window?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
*manteeep nih kak , aku modal 20k jadi 4,3juta dong..Untuk cara nya bisa di cek di youtube ini*
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Hybrid raid capability is a big plus for my video editing use case. What is the most straight forward way to tell if a NAS has hybrid raid? The Asustor 12 M.2 Nvme NAS is currently at the top of my list to buy. – does it have hybrid raid?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
You’re wide array of words you use to mean a British pound has always confused me when you talk about prices. I always wondered, is there that many different currencies in the UK? I finally had to look it up tonight. I guess they’re all synonymous.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks for posting this. It’s always entertaining to watch. So, more or less niqqers is better?
Between these squids and niqqers I’m getting confused.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I have two 1821+ boxes in a cluster and I “accidentally” put 64GB of memory in them. They’ve been running about 6 months and I haven’t seen any issues, but I’m wondering if you see any drawbacks or potential problems.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
SHR and a thousand dollars cheaper is why I went with the DS1821+
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
1824?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
How much longer do you think we need to wait for a DS1824+?
My question is when it does arrive will it use the same DX517 expansion unit?
I am thinking of adding a DX517 to my current 1019+ to keep me going until the new 8 bay arrives and when it does get here for me to buy I can also add the expansion unit to it.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks Rob. Validated my decision. I was pretty sure though that SSDs on the 1821+ could only be used as cache, not a storage pool?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
You missed the Out of Band management on the DS1823xs. How do you add that to the DS1821+
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
The ONLY thing stopping me getting the DS1821+ is FOMO. If they brought out a DS2124+ with even mild processor bump I’d have it in my basket now. Only concern is if they restrict hard disk usage. Other than that, this does everything I need.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
1621xs+ is just fine
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
@nascompares, thank you for the video, I was looking at these two models just this morning to evaluate for my non-profit.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I think the biggest deal breaker for DS1823xs+ is that it support Synology brand HDDs that are very pricy. You should have mentioned that,
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Really good video and very happy to hear i can stay on my 1821+ Unfortunately i couldn’t find your patreon link in the description. Had to find it elsewhere
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
for some reason, i imagine the videos are filmed inside a shipping storage container by some import/export harbour docks… explaining the seagulls and the immediate access to new nas products from china. ????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
It’s possible to install a used and cheap Intel 10GbE NIC in the DS1821+.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thank you for creating another fun and informative video. Would it be possible to make a video using the same parameters for similar Qnap products? I’m currently skittish about Synology due to their move to proprietary drives, cards and memory. I’m a photographer/filmmaker who has 75T of images stored on many drives and is looking to build a large highly searchable (image and facial) database. Thanks again.
P.s I’m currently studying 3D and AI generated set design and location building using Unreal Engine and Stable Diffusion AI on a Macbook Pro M1.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
As an Ex Drobo user, I’m in love with the ability to pull and replace drives live, and the array rebuilds itself. The SHR seriously intrigues me. I’m wrestling with BYO or going with premade, but haven’t pulled the trigger quite yet.
What are the recovery options on a dead/dying drive?
What about in-place upgrades/replacement of drives if I fill things out?
Is there a desktop app I can install for Windows that will tell me when a drive needs replacing?
Can I easily move drives from one branded NAS to another?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I’m waiting for the DS1824+ to replace my DS1813+. Hope it’s coming soon. Thanks for the video anyway!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I bought each of these, the cheaper for home and the 23xs+ for my office. First thing I did on the 21+ was add in a 10Gb card. I used a hack I found to make the 23xs+ support SHR. 😀
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Great video Rob! I standardize my business on DS1821+. I stick 32GB RAM and a duel 10GbE NIC in them. Video production is what we use them for and they crush the workload!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I’m brand new to NAS systems (I’m still within my first week). I originally purchased my DS423+ solely for Plex movies storage based on your recommendation. Since then I’ve started moving my music as well (my wife and I have SO many CDs so time to work toward getting rid of Apple Music). Your explanations have been so helpful on this early journey and I’ve learned something new from every video I’ve watched. Before watching this video I was always bothered by the DS423s limit on 1GBE. Today I learned about Link Aggregation!! After I’m done with this current video I’ll be looking for more information on that. I also have been cruising the Nascompares website (helped me update my ram). Thank you so much for all of this! Brilliant!!!!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
As much as I love your videos, Rob, the frustration with the seagulls is always a highlight! 😀
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Do you consult?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I was really interested in this until i heard no shr and only synology hdds….what a pitty.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Where are the seagalls?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I don’t mean to spam. I put this in an older video for the same.
Thank you for the review of this product.
I have been giving consideration to it and the form factor along with the SSD’s does have an appeal. This would be a home use application that does have SD, HD and 4k movies. There is also a fairly large amount of music files as MP3 and video as well. Other than that, it’s all about data and the combined volume is in and around 7TB. Again; home use two users.
The question: what Drives of good quality would you recommend? I also understand through reading, the device is RAID capable. Is that part correct?
In advance, thank you!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thank you for the very interesting vid! Should you start using , say, six nvme modules to build a RAID 5 system adding at a later stage 2-4 nvme modules would you be able to expand total size of existing RAID without rebuilding it from scratch ?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
God I love your videos. I’m looking at a new NAS and this popped up on my search and my first thought was “I wonder if that NASCompares dude has a video about it?”
Of course at a touch over an hour long, you did not disappoint!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Only compatible with they own VERY expensive hard drives (made by toshiba and not that good). If you buy another HD brand will get NO support from Synology and the system will fill up of warnings. Can’t believe that Synology is making this decision! After 15 years buying synology NAS, its time to try QNAP’s.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
No compatibility with 3rd party HDD. Synology’s HD costs more than twice than Seagate Ironwolf PRO. Can’t believe they did that….
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Great video !
Looking to this TS-855X (to replace my old Synology DS413) and not to a new Synology (I already own a DS1821+): this is because Synology wants to oblige their customers to use their own Synology branded NVMe, RAM and disks !
The built-in 10Gb is important for me because I work essentially with large video files, and the 2xSATA bays (with no restriction to create a storage pool on them) is a must have for the VMs.
And I will not be afraid to be in the mess after each operating system update (with Synology I am always afraid that they lock some functions because they detect a non Synology component) !
Now I am about to watch your videos related to QTS and QuTS: still a bit afraid by the “inconstitencies” that you mention in this video…
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
It’s a shame asussor put such a low powered cpu motherboard combo in there ,I would have loved to see a zyzen aib or it’s version also they really missed a trick by not allowing it to be used as a fast access cashe for its larger gen 2 or small business models
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Fantastic video! I’m new to NAS. I want to setup this device with 12 SSDs and make it automatically backup my various PCs on a monthly schedule. Will this unit and its software let me do that? Thanks.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
From the reviews I have seen it seems like a slightly faster cpu would have been perfect to max out a 10g nic but it is pretty cheap
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
On the market for a new NAS and was thinking about future-proofing the setup. I think some limitations on this machine are in effect to serve a specific niche crowd (the traveler who wants to take their NAS with them). Now I understand that this is why they decided to go for M.2 NVMe drives, I realize now they did not select the M.2 for the performance but to keep the case small. Initially, I wanted this device for its power, but the more I think about it I realize that I’m not the intended audience.
If the 12-slot machine had a CPU with more cores and a bit better performance it would have been a no-brainer. It would instantly replace my home lab and store my data. But besides that, failing drives always makes me nervous and in the past when rebuilding an array it happened to me more than once that other drives started to fail while rebuilding. Being throttled by the 8 PCIe while rebuilding an array is something I really do not like… Then again, it has SSDs and not spinning disks, so performance should already be improved compared to what I’m used to.
I really like the choice of a 10Gbit network port and choice for HDMI. M.2 would be awesome if the PCIe lanes were there to support it.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thank you so much! Do you know if I can set up a custom database service on that device to make it a Davinci Resolve server for collaborative video workflow in DVR?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
is this true that I can’t use WD or Seagate drives with this unit and I am only forced to use only the Synology drives? Thx
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I tried to google what’s the best practice or storage ratio for all the hardware and i couldn’t find anything useful.
I’m looking to install 3x 10 TB HDD and 2 SSD with 2 M.2
What’s the recommended m.2 and ssd storage i should attach to them ? @NASCompares
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
LOL – it’s not affordable at all, but I’d love to own one! 🙂
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Seeing comments about extremely loud PSU fan. Is that the case?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
How do I get to this web-based GUI? I can only access wirh ACC or AiMaster. Is there a feature I need to turn on?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Is it compactable with Dual-Port Thunderbolt 3 Expansion Card ? MFR #QXP-T32P
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
thanks for your review. I’m about to go for the 12-bay one but I have doubts. It is only for Max studio in 10gb network. could you configure 2x2tb raid 1 (Time Machine) 4×2 raid 5 for Final Cut? and 2×2 raid 1 for Max applications and the nas itself? Could you do it little by little? first system apps then finalcut…. etc (for not having to spend all of one. Would you be able to do that and manage the different raids? Obviously you would look at the ram you have and expand it. Do you know what the Maximum is? I understand it will be ddr4 or dimm 2666? Thanks for your attention
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I have an HP Proliant gen 8 server. Pretty good and didn’t cost nearly as much.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Hello. Great review! Is it clear to the user which SSD slots share a PCI lane? I’m thinking dividing the 12 slots into 3 RAID arrays would maximize write performance.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
at this point, M.2 are slowly getting cheaper than SATA SSDs, but still with bandwidth limitations, something like four QVOs can do equally well in budget Synology device, with SMB Multichannel enabled speeds would be similar, no?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
….but will it LAST anytime past it’s WARRANTY??????? I purchased the QNAP TVS-672XT (in 2020) with all the WIZ BANG “future proof” features at the time and out of NOWHERE the entire system JUST QUITE (NO BOOT). The only “immediate” solution from QNAP (in order to access your data) is to ????PURCHASE A NEW QNAP DEVICE???? and move the hard drives over.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
truly affordable £789 ; yeah real cheap £200 max is it’s worth unpopulated
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I need help
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
love the video. i have a some what related Question, can it support the SABRENT M.2 NVMe SSD 8TB Gen 4?? forget speed i am looking to build a DAS out of Nvme ssd’s so here is the question in detail (if i buy this device and put in it 12 SABRENT M.2 NVMe SSD 8TB Gen 4 for a total of 96TB storage and never connect the eathernet cable to it, just connect it to my pc via usb connection and set up the raid system for it, will it work????? ) i keep looking for a NVME ssd enclousere that takes that many ssds but most are big bulky and take like 4) . so can it work ?????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Dude, one hour!!! Respect. Can we get iSCSI performance review with ESXi server over 10GB.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
to slow
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
What’s next, IBM 286 NASes? This is ridiculous
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Would this work for 2 or 3 Apple Final Cut users editing footage gathered on iPhones?
Would the storage via ethernet feel almost equal to that on a MacBook?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I am not sure if you have done this recently or not.. But i want to know how the qnap software compares to the synology software??? I have a qnap now, but it’s slow as heck and it’s 1 year. I have noticed it being a huge resource hog and the only thing i really run on it is jellyfin which runs way better than plex… I have a drive to drive raid which leaves me with 24TB. of useful drive spare or so. 6 8TB Ironwolf nas drives. Just slow as heck and if Synology is better, i would like to know so i can switch…
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
It’s amazing to think that for about $5,000 today, you can get the storage and performance that outclasses the datacenters of all major banks from fifteen to twenty years ago.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
this cpu in a 2 bay that would be great for a home nas
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
This might be a silly question but if I wanted to use this as an NVR for 3 POE cameras would this be a good choice? Or should I look to go the Synology route? Thanks in advance!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Should we worry about most cheap nvme drives do not support trim on raid 5/6?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
1399 dollar for an intel atom and 8 gigs of ram? Isnt that a little bit expensive? Because more hardware isnt included.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I used to work in Enterprise Storage, EMC, Hitachi, NetApp, as well as many others who appeared and disappeared. I spent years of my life working in these areas. This video and your content (I stumbled across one of your blogs for the DS1821), is beyond epic, it’s a gift. This video covered everything I wanted to know. Thanks so much for your efforts.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Silly question but does this (and NAS drives in general) require to be hooked up to the internet to work, or can it be used like a standard external hard drive and simply plugged into a USB port to be accessed by the respective computer?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Can i use one drive and after few weeks add second one and create raid 1 without losing data from first drive?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
In Poland it is available and ready @ stock for 1666Eur.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Basically a mini 12/1688X
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
You mentioned that QNAP could have put U.2 bays instead of SATA SSD bays and TS-h973AX has U.2 bays. But TS-h973AX does not have any PCIe slots.
The CPU has limited amounts of PCIe lanes. We can make a PCIe slot or make a U.2 bay. But each 3X4 U.2 bay we make is 1 less 3X4 PCIe slot we can make when it comes to using a CPU with a limited amount of PCIe.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Nice review m8 and not a half bad NAS. Still, Atom, I’ll give it a miss. Also IIRC Asustor has a 10 bay NAS in this price range with dual NVMe and 2.5GbE (and Atom SoC). Push comes to shove I’d rather have that then this but Atom SOC’s just aren’t worth it to me.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
What I would appreciate to understand is if you fully max it out, put it on a 10Gbe switch, what speeds do you get at the end of the line? 4K video editing?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Great, detailed review.
Love what you do on your channel!
P.S. BTW, not sure if it is different in the UK, but here in the States the term “kickback” generally means “a payment made to someone who has facilitated an illicit transaction.” Probably not what you meant, though? ????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
So similar to the QNAP TS-h973AX-8G @ £979 minus the 4 x U.2 NVMe SSD and replaced with 2 x 2,5″ sata drives. Get 4 x U.2 NVMe SSD caddies for M2 NVMe drives and get 2 more bays for £300 approx less? Processor AMD Ryzen Embedded V1000 series V1500B 4-core/8-thread, 2.2 GHz processor with up to 64 GB DDR4 RAM ECC memory.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Nice review.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Do you answer questions from viewers? I was wondering how it ran virtual machines.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
It’s not possible to get 10 000 Megs? What unit are you referring to? Why aren’t you mentionning TB instead of MB or at least GB? are you talking about capacity or speed? IF you’re talking about speed why aren’t you saying capacity per unit of time? Like MB per second?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
12 4TB drives 16RAM MTS900 RAID 0 800MBS sustained 68% processor RAID 5 450-550MBS sustained 81% processor. Spinning drive NAS can easily handle large 1-1.2GBs writes. Reads on the USB ports of NTFS NVMe drive are unbelieveably slow (using the file program on the device). When deleting a volume and recreating one after it’s done the web interface becomes fuzzy and unreadable so you have to log out and back in. So the file transfer performance is a little off. Would I buy one again? Probably. It’s a very good value for what it offers. It’s uber portable. It’s tiny. Very low power consumption. It’s only 50W but it’s the warmest 50W I’ve ever felt. It will probably put Asustor on the map. You’re not going to want to put a spinning drive NAS that can handle what this does in your carry on.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
First impressions: it looks like a sideways view of a Courier HST (well, you are taking a trip down memory lane).
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Do you think m.2 with heat sinks would fit in there?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I have a 4 bay lockster now. Use for file sharing in a home office with four users. Had it in service for 5 years. Has 2 4tb hard drives not even close to full. Wanting to upgrade and use the older model for a backup device. I would like 10gb access. Which is better solution flashstor or locker. Locker is advertised more for gaming and plex. Not sure of the advatages it would serve for file sharing. Hdd per gig still cheaper on standard hdd.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Is not need ECC RAM for a reliable NAS?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Go and see a dentist to get your teeth fixed.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
You’ll need to include a “knicker to currency” exchange rate in your videos.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Only if it was in an aluminum case, removable network adapter, more memory and have my cpu power. Everything less is awesome.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
To me it all starts and ends with the CPU, they messed that so much that I’m gonna skip this and not even blink
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Is it possible to implement RDMA or SMB Direct or RoCeV2 with an all flash NAS? Even other brands? Windows has supported RDMA for almost a decade now, but it seems QNAP, Synology, Asustor, etc do not support any RDMA protocols that will actually enable speeds up to 100 Gb/s with 100 Gb NICs. Im running into a brutal 55 Gb/s bottleneck and it seems to be that the NAS does not support any of these RDMA options. Are there any NAS systems that ACTUALLY, really, truly do support AND are capable of 100 Gb/s?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Out of stock or 1-2 month wait. Looks like a fun device. I’ll take another look when it’s more widely available.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
On first glance, the first use case for one of these that I can think of is for off grid use – cottage, boat, motor-home / trailer (caravan). The NVMe storage is just too expensive vs HDD’s for uses that many of us would have especially if that is media heavy. But, from what i can find online, the power consumption of NVME’s is only about 25% of HDD’s. And that means less consumption of battery power.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thank you, boss, for your effort, do you think Flashstor 12 Pro is good enough to install the proxmox backup server with 10Gb linked to switch 10Gb too, I will use it for delay backup in my full rack in my colocation in London?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Is the ten gige port actually multi-gige 2.5/5/10? The other pci card they sell is multi gige.. this would save $ not buying for other model.????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I just received and setup my 6 drive version. I installed 4x 4TB Crucial RAID5. I’ll get 2 more soon I suspect but am hoping 8TB NVMe’s will get cheaper. I have to say the experience was superb! Very straight forward. I’ve had a Synology DS918 for the last 5 years and both are good, but I find the Asustor a bit easier to use.
The Asustor Folder app was amazing for making easy to copy content from my backup ext 16TB drive. Simply drag the files from the USB attached ext drive to the folder I want, and done.
I’ve got 1 of teh 2.5GBit ethernets in use and get ~270-280MB/s transfer from my PC too! Very nice! So much better than the 112MB/s on my Synology.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Nobody says “Nicker” nowadays… but thanks for the flashback ????????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
hello sir. do you have/can you make a video about recovering data files from nas drives? my ts-451 failed but the drives are qood. sadly they are not ntfs so windows cannot read them. thank you.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
So it probably would be great as a media server, albeit with “dumbed down” / early generation SSDs?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Why do you always pronounce Ryzen “Ryzon”?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Hi NASCompare, thank you for all of your video, it does help me a lot in choosing NAS that I want. Can I check with you whether DS223+ support active business backup? Thank you.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
DIY version 4bay Nvme+2 2.5ssd : Inwin Chopin or B2 itx , amd itx board with dual nvme , 5600G or 5300G , pcie split enabled and slap on a 8/4/4 pcie riser .
Now you got 4nvme with 4lanes to each drive plus two 2.5 drive bay
You still got a free x8 pcie slot
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
What are the chances of getting a video loading truenas on this?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
But, it just looks so, ugly!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Damn, I thought you were going to say the NAS is unbelievably also 250 knicker!! Tut, now it’s expensive!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
No UK stock anywhere ????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Is using NVMe SSDs a good idea? I have heard that after awhile with constant READ/WRITE SSDs wear out. Heck my computer recommends NOT defragging the SSD. With that said, I have had my Surface Book 2 since 2018 with no issues. I am shopping for a solid inexpensive NAS and this one looks interesting. I do video and photo editing and I need a NAS with decent performance and large capacity.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I think we know what’s missing here… based on Asustor product naming convention, IMAGINE that : Asustor Flashtor 6 Pro FS6706X (yes 6-bay 10G) for $599 🙂
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I have a synology ds1821+ which is loaded with 16tb drives which I use only for video editing + huge amounts of video file storage and pictures and have 10gb switch and It works well but is noisy when the drives spin up. Would using this Asustor NAS filled with 4tb or 8tb drives be better speed wise and without the noise, heat and power use when it’s left on 24/7?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Will qlc be good for esxi nfs share of datastore or it that going to be to many writes ?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
First of all thank you for your clear and complete review.
What I do not understand with this NAS is the intended market:
With 12 drive slots, the prosumer seems to be addressed.
However, a prosumer wants hot swappable drives and absolutely no power down to add or replace a drive. Unscrewing the case to get to the drives is also not on the wish list.
Is it something for the home user? Want those 12 drive bays?
All in all, I don’t see a market for a product like this. But I could be wrong. The sales figures will tell the truth.
But thanks again because it is precisely through these kinds of clarifying reviews that customers can make the right choice.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
How is Photo Gallery 3 + AiFoto 3 experience with it?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
1. The product page on the Asustor website indicates that the DSD audio is supported via the Hi-Res Player app. But according to the Asustor Compatibility – USB DAC webpage, none of the supported DACs support DSD.
2. Per the Asustor M.2 SSD Compatibility list, the only 4TB drive supported is the Gen3 WD Red WDS400T1R0C-68BDK0. There are plenty of other worthwhile 4TB Gen4 drives available at the same cost. Those aren’t supported by the FS6712X.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I hope Synology will also bring an affordable version of the Flashstation
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
29:27 Nooooooo We got Synullified! Flashstation Oh geez.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
14:14 The seagulls are trying to tell you that we don’t have enough PCI Express for another Gigabit port, but we have the USB port for our 2.5-Gigabit adapter if you wanna do that.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
As far as I’m concerned, even neglecting the (not indifferent) problems related to CPU performance and PCIe lanes, Asustor currently certifies only one 4TB M.2 HDD model, the WD Red SN700, which where I live comes to cost 379€ which multiplied by 12 makes the silliness of 4.548€… to have almost 41TB of available space in RAID 5.
If I bought a 6 bay NAS with 6 20TB disks (ex. Exos X20) I would pay around €1.824 which in RAID 5 translates into around 93TB of available space.
41TB for 4.548€ (110€ / TB) Vs 93TB for 1.824€ (19€ / TB)
For my needs (my CD / DVD / BRD / BRD-UHD ripped available on Plex / minimserver at 1:1 quality, my photos and a few family videos shot on a MiniDV years ago), I’d say there’s nowhere near competition. ..
The fact that the NAS costs little is irrelevant.
BTW: nice video, as usual ????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Hello! We’re back to watch the featured presentation of Robbie rambling on about this NAS for an hour. We can’t complain if we’re getting what is quite honestly the longest video on the channel. We love his ramblings. But we’re here and busting out the popcorn to watch a video that is way better than any movie I can see at the cinema. And while we do that, we’re just happy to answer your comments, questions, praise, and criticism! Sit back and bootstrap on. It’s a doozy!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I am looking to go for this nas. The problem is that in my home I don’t hame a 10gb network. I can buy I 10gbe switch but the cabling I already have going through my walls is very difficult to change. Is the cabling going to be a huge bottleneck for the 10gbe. Is there a reason for me to change to a 10gbe switch without changing the cables? Am I going to get any benefits by doing so, even if I would not be able to reach 10gbe?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
What about online video conversion performance ?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
How many ads in this video? Annoying
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
So if I have an SHR partition on my current system, can I buy this and swap my drives or will it not be able to read off my current SHR raid setup?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Bought it with the link, hope this helps. thanks for all the content.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
So… 800€ more than the ds1821+, no SHR, higher TDP CPU with minor processing improvements, still no gpu, short hardware compatibility list and 2x more expensive Synology drives. 10Gbe interface which can be replicated on the ds1821+ for 50 bucks (compatible Intel card).
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Glad I can across the video, I was about to make the purchase.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Is that means we can not use any harddisk except Synology brand?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
ECC support?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
But will it Plex?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
If I store 1440p or 4K video on a DS1823xs+, is it possible to view or preview the videos on the NAS?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Canadian here, what is a knicker?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
A 1200$ NAS that has a CPU with a 20% less powerful CPU than the venerable 920+? Thats a hard sell but I guess for a pure file server it would be quite powerful. Still the 1821+ has like twice the power with a similar price…
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Looks like you could change the 10gb SFP ports with an M.2 adapter to add 1 or 2, 2.5gbe ports easy enough. The pci slot if working could add a whole new scale of hacking a dremel work :0
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Need to get a bigger NAS and currently use an old DS418play. I’m using it for movies, mostly 4k. How does this perform in respect to plex and emby? I hear conflicting stories that you should avoid Terramaster for media.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks for the review, Rob!
This look like a quite capable machine and I do like, that they include 2 NVMe slots.
I’m not quite convinced regarding the form factor of the device. I would prefer a rack mount version, but the only viable rack mount NAS from Terramaster (U4-423) only has a single NVMe slot.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I purchased this unit when it first came out and I had network performance issues on TOS OS on the 10gb nic – there was packet loss and other than loading the web UI when only connected thru 10gb sfp+ the device was pretty much useless for file transfers (my goal was to push data from my linux 10gb NAS to this and benchmark it but w/o proper driver support from the TOS it was impossible so I returned it).
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I feel like this is an Unraid box!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Nice work sir !! Looks like a nice little unit too !! Is it quiet ?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Cool
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Nice!
I would say they are truly the challengers of the industry, quite affordable and still powerful…
Thanks for bringing this to our attention!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Ryz*E*n, noy Ryzon.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
A NAS that you can’t put hardrives in = useless.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I currently have a DS1019+ which in which I have 5 drives installed. 3-10TB, 1-12TB, 1-14TB.. I know this is using SHR and that the xs+ line does not allow you to “create” SHR volumes, however I have been told I can move my SHR volume to the DS1823XS+. My question relates to Plex, how does the 1823xs+ work with PLEX? I currently use the NVIDIA shield as the client to view MPEG movies I have stored on my NAS. Will it still work on the 1823xs+ and how would performance compare to the DS1019+.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
my first NAS was a Drobo, it had a volume limit of 16 TB , when 4TB+ disks arrived it quickly became outdated. now so many synology products, even 12 bay ones have 108 volume limit. now with 18TB + and higher disks its really becoming a bottleneck
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
will it only have 108 volume limit? seems nobody talks about it but its becoming a bigger problem
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
So what will actually happen when I install WD drives into the NAS? Will it refuse to work or simply warn me about incompatible drives?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Why did it take them this long to make this? Is it really that hard for a big company that does that for a living? And why is it lacking one of its main functionality that everyone mentiones? Did they forgot? Are they incompetent? Is it on purpose?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
In the near future we will need to buy their electricity to run their products. Just to make sure we get the best experience offcourse.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Given its a summary of the earlier video, I suspect I’ll stop here.
Unfortunate re the hard drive limitations and lack of SHR.
Ideally we could retrofit the 1823xs+ motherboard into a 1821+ while retaining freedom re drive selection and SHR.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I’m so happy I purchased my 1821+ before this one was released when the price was $900. Now you can’t find it for less than $1.5K. What the DS1823+ will look like?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I’m so frustrated how they have basically no options for 6+ bay that are good for transcoding. I like to use mine for a multitude of functions but transcoding large video files is one of them and Synology falls flat on all their offerings unless you want a 4 bay. Qnapp it is which sucks since I have purchased many add ons, software and know their OS well. Come on, Synology!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
please please please do nvme benchmarking in next video…
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Still wondering if and when there will be a DS1823+ ? I would be happy with a DS1821+ and a 10GBe network card, but I would prefer a DS1823+ if there will be one… It’s already end of March 2023. What’s Synology’s past history when they came out with new versions of their NAS?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I’d love to hear comparision between ds1821 and this one…
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
So another overpriced BS product with close to zero flexibility, running on a 4+ yo CPU, with even less oomph than 10+ yo i7, indeed “server-grade”, huh. Delusional behavior from Synology continues.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
What annoys me is, that with Xeon – to – AMD switch , max memory size is limited to 32GB. Its just not enough, especially for such expensive device like XS series.
I was waiting for some really usable solution for virtualization with fast VMM package, powerful processor and memory enough. Unfortunately, its mission impossible on Synology. VMM is just old and slow package itself and 32GB max memory is another killer. So for virtualization i still need standard dedicated server or QNAP NAS. No solution from Synology, that’s really annoying me.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
It would be cheaper to get a bay expander for my 1522+ and a NUC dedicated to plex/VMs to make up for CPU performance.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
No shr, only Synology Hdds supported. No thank you.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
At $2000 that seems like a good price point to consider building your own… $2000 seems super-overpriced for what this is
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
This is a nice unit but I would stay with a + system for my needs. I already have two Synology DS216J’s and really want to use my current drives in the new unit for later upgrades to higher capacity drives down the road. Thanks for this, you are a great NAS salesman. No matter which brand.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I regret buying a QNAP TS-873A and been casting my eye over the Synology range more and more again.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Well this nas is out of the question…. Shame really
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Can you test this and see if WD Red Pros work with it? Also will non Synology ssds work and which ones?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Can you put a 40gbs Network card in the DS1823xs+?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Really suppressing ssd caching on none synology m.2 ssds ? ????
Right of repair should extend to this. We do pay happily a premium for the dsm software. So give us a red light but don’t prevent us to use other m.2 ssds. Getting ssd cache is the killer feature for most users so don’t degrade your competitive advantage.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Hi, i need some help from you.
I’m thinking of replacing my Qnap-NAS with the Synology DS1621xs+. However, i have a hardware related question you might be able to help me with: I’m thinking of putting Samsung PM893 SATA-SSDs (8TB) in it since there is a special deal here at the moment. I would be very glad, if you could tell me, if they make sense in this NAS (also for Raid F1)? …and if you see any problem with using the Samsungs over Ironwolfs and WD Reds (i don’t really need that many TBWs for my use case –> mosly Plex Server and for Backups)?
Thank you in advance!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Funny. I was looking at this very unit this week thinking the title of the video verbatim.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
only hdd from syno? no thanks
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Waiting for DS1623+ ????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Waaaaayyyyy toooo EXPENSIVE!!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I hate that synology sets these bonkers restrictions on their devices and also the restrictions can seriously vary from device to device. They are shooting themselves in the foot because of this dumb decision
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Synology are lost – Compatibility is a disaster.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thanks for the great content!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
The only thing I use a Synology for is photo backup at home (in addition to the cloud). Is a system like this more than needed? Already have a 1819+. Thanks.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I’m in disbelief that this new NAS does not support SHR (Synology Hybrid Raid). I was excited to buy this new model DS1823xs+ but then discovering it does does not include all drive formats, as simplistic as SHR. It should be compatible for all formatted drives. So migrating my system from an old NAS with SHR to this one is not possible? I have to completely rebuild from a new NAS? That’s inexcusable for Synology. I can live with the shift to only supporting their own HDD and even SATA only, but how many older Synology NAS owners that want a seamless migration to a new NAS is Synology alienating with this move? I hope it comes on a future update, because that is ridiculous.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Is there a way to access the download log of Synology Photos when an album is shared? Has this feature been removed altogether or move to the general log application? This very handy feature existed in DS Photo and I have not been able to find something equivalent in DSM 7.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
this nas is mouth watering to me
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thks & again !DS1823+ or Bust!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I bought the DS1821+ just because this nonsense HDD locked. I’m using 4x 4tb ssd reds. Bummer there’s no F1.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
My god. Synology I pay for C2. Bought the SV3400 to use with the DS3018XS and E10M20-T1. I can’t use it. Only the 3500. Makes no sense they are restricting and forgot they own NVME. I was able to use a sabrant. LOL. I’m on the 4th sonolenta. But it’s becoming bitter. I’m happily paying for their services but looking to leaving just because the hardware is aways underpowered and now become restricted.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
No SHR and won’t use my drives = no buy. It’s really shitty of Synology to do this.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Drobo was so easy. I have the 8 bay N. And an 8 bay D. And two 5 bay Drobo.
One of the 5 bays died and I’m confident I can get the info off it using the one that is working. So I’m trying to find an 8 bay to start moving away from Drobo.
This looked great. It’s just barely affordable for me until I looked at the prices of the synology drives. And if I’m understanding raid correctly I’ve got to have all the drives up front.
I guess the 1812+ is what I need. I just didn’t want to buy something 2 years old.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Very nice video. Boo on you tube broken recommendation. This channel would be bigger and help more people
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Very nice video. Boo on you tube broken recommendation. This channel would be bigger and help more people
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Will E10M20-T1 work with this NAS? If yes, can I utilize that two m.2. SSDs as a nvme pool or part of a nvme pool?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Do they force you into their enterprise drives for this model?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Great video! I am thinking of getting a nas for editing and video work and would love to be able to hook up 10g to both my mac and pc. Is there a way to format/setup the raid so that I can access the same video files with both mac and pc? I tried searching but and a little lost of what the best option would be. Thanks!!!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Not Intel. So no transcoding. It’s almost the primary reason I have a NAS. I’ll keep my old Synology for files, but will one day get a new QNAP for my media.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
A no go for me…
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
If XS series, should have had an infiniband expansion connection, not eSata…
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
No combo pcie card also?’ Rip off…
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
No SHR?!?! Wow
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
And expensive to boot!! ????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Wished I’d not purchased the QNAP TS-873A tbh.
Had it two months and might ditch it for a Synology unit. Not this unit due to the drive limitations.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I just want to say thank you so much I have watched many videos of you in the recent time and decided to get a second hand DS918+, it’s user friendly, cheap, has integrated graphics and is plenty powerful for my usecase. Keep up the good work you help a lot of people with your knowledge and tips and tricks.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I wonder if Synology, going the AMD route, will ever throw a Threadripper in their high end lineup.
It would probably be too expensive for be ”just a NAS”.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Could’ve been, But forces you to use synology drives so its a no-no, back to purchasing another 1621xs+.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
There’s irony insofar that Syno’s SSD-10GbE combo card itself acts as a heatsink for drives put on it… that are then nerfed out of use because… Synology doing Synology things.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Great work keep it up.
The lagging of the OS and subsequent apologising about it really irritated me. Just like lagging does on my own PC. Next time maybe have a few VM’s disabled for the rest of the demos.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Can’t find one to order online in the U.S. Anyone find one in the U.S.?
Rob, keep up the good work! Your reviews are great!
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I agree, the chassis is solid. I recently purchased my first Synology, a DS1821+ using the same chassis and it is nice to see metal cases still on the market in a world of plastic housings.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
OK, I personally work for Syno, so I know this system couple months:) but man you’re talking about NAS servers with such passion, that I really enjoyed this review.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Robbie loves his 10GbE ! ❤????????????????????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Can’t you upgrade it to DSM 6?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Great video as always. I suspect the reason the add-on PCIe card doesn’t support 10 GBe + SSD is a lack of available PCIe lanes. That’s probably also the reason that the internal SSDs are limited to 1000MB/s.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Question: how do NASs perform in write-heavy environments like being used as an NVR for a surveillance system?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
No shr and only Synology “approved” hard disks. Too bad.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I agree: the 6bay wasn’t truly big enough for RAID6 and consider a hot spare if the support individual is off-site. 8bay has the capacity to still be respectable after set-up.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Re : the missing SHR. I can see a new service / sale opportunity for you to provide Robbie. Selling sets of drives that you have setup with SHR that you can populate DS1823xs+ ‘s with when you sell them. Configure the drives with ShR in another Synology NAS and migrate them before shipping.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
❤️ your videos, might want to try stop saying again so much though
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Blimey i just ordered the 821+ for £999. so need to know is this better ?? And wnat a mix of drives 4x18tb and 4×12
( comjng from drobo 8d)
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I was looking at this as a replacement for my DS1817+, but no SHR? No 3rd party HDD? No thanks. I’ll hope the upgrade to the currently selling DS1821+ comes before the end of the year and with a decent processor. The 1821+ could barely be called an “upgrade” to my 1817 as it is now.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
does this system transcode ? if this is a no then its a fail
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Instead of buying one DS1823xs for ~1800$, it might be better to buy two DS923+ with two 10gb cards for a total of 1500$.
It gives a total of 4 NVME SSDs, additional redundancy, less cost and same ability to add 2 drive expansions.
Speaking about expansions which costs 500$, does not includes CPU, memory and so on, again it might be resonable to buy a whole new additional DS923+ for a 600$ (only 100$ more).
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
In order to watch this long of video, I would have to be assured there are seagull sounds somewhere in the presentation. ????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thank you for the incredibly in-depth review.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Well done Rob, shame it doesn’t have a SFP+ 10G eh?
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
I still rock my DS1517+. I’m due for an update since it cannot andle 4k transcoding. Wonder if they will eventually released a DS1523+ not AMD base so I can transcode.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
As a Drobo 5D3 user. I am going to suggest that a NAS is not exactly a “replacement”
Additionally neither is the Thunderbay 8 that OWC produces.
What I have ended up doing as a stop-gap measure is purchase a basment level NAS from Synology 220j ($115) and pop a pair of 18TB drives in it for my Video’s.
and I went for the Ugreen 5 bay RAID box ($120) and reused my 5 10TB drives I had in my Drobo.
Neither one is a speed demon but it allows me to not have to buy all new Hard Drives and gives me the reliability I had with Drobo
(My drobo has survived for 10 years and I am hopeful Drobo will at some point return to the market)
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thank you very much Rob for doing a great job. Thank you very much for treating these really well thought through videos. Appreciate your opinion. Love, Greg
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
Thank you for a great review and it is very nice but a couple of tiers over my humble needs. Cheers
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
the 108TB Volume limit is a big bummer for the price, and they have no 20TB or 22TB drives… Sad day
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
waiting for the cheaper DS1823+????
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
bad prozessor 🙁
REPLY ON YOUTUBE
*Note* – A couple of bits of housekeeping. First up, I know this is a LOOOOOOONG video. The much, MUCH shorter ‘Before You Buy’ video will be live next week, but I wanted to get the massive Hardware and Software review live first. In the 2-3 weeks I will be publishing the 10GbE performance testing, VM testing, Plex Tests and more, but rather than make this video even longer and make you guys wait, I have moved these to their own videos as usual. Last thing, I had a rotten cold when I was filming the software portion of this video and you can DEFINITELY tell. Apologies for sounding ‘flurgy’ at points. Have a fantastic weekend and the written review of the DS1823xs+ NAS will be live on NASCompares later today.
REPLY ON YOUTUBE